SMT, PCB Electronics Industry News
  • SMTnet
  • »
  • Industry News
  • »
  • IPC Criticizes Bad Science, Methodology In Greenpeace Electronics Guide

IPC Criticizes Bad Science, Methodology In Greenpeace Electronics Guide

Nov 15, 2010

BANNOCKBURN, IL - IPC — Association Connecting Electronics Industries® is criticizing the "bad science" in the latest revision to Greenpeace’s electronics scorecard, "Guide to Greener Electronics." The guide rates consumer electronics companies against Greenpeace criteria on hazardous substances, take back and recycling, and energy use and climate change. IPC has made the following statement on the Guide:

"Greenpeace continues to mark down leading consumer electronics manufacturers for failing to lobby for an agenda based on faulty science. Several computer manufacturers received lower scores for not aggressively removing brominated flame retardants (BFRs) from their products.

The science does not support the need to phase out all BFRs. In fact, the World Health Organization and the European Commission's Scientific Committee on Health and Environmental Risks conducted separate, comprehensive scientific assessments of Tetrabromobisphenol-A (TBBPA), a widely used BFR, and both found TBBPA to be safe for human health and the environment.

In addition, IPC, on behalf of our members, is extremely concerned about Greenpeace’s tactics in penalizing companies for ‘failing to openly support restrictions on ... brominated flame retardants (BFRs)….’ In fact, Greenpeace provides specific wording it would like to see companies use in calling for an expansion of the RoHS Directive to include the ban of BFRs.

Demonizing certain substances without a scientific basis can lead industries to adopt substances that have a greater environmental impact or that cause resources to be inefficiently used. IPC calls on nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and regulators to adopt scientific principles in the evaluation and banning of any chemicals and substances."

Facts on the Greenpeace ranking criteria are available at http://www.ipc.org/ehs/greenpeace. They include:

Ranking Criteria: Substituting harmful chemicals in the production of electronics will prevent worker exposure to these substances and contamination of communities that neighbor production facilities.

Fact: The World Health Organization and the European Commission’s Scientific Committee on Health and Environmental Risks (SCHER) conducted separate, comprehensive scientific assessments of TBBPA and both found TBBPA to be safe for human health and the environment.

Fact: In Europe, the flame retardant industry’s Voluntary Emissions Control Action Programme (VECAP) has reduced manufacturing-related releases of TBBPA to air and water to less than one kilogram total in 2009.

Ranking Criteria: Eliminating harmful substances will also prevent leaching/offgassing of chemicals like brominated flame retardants (BFR) during use, and enable electronic scrap to be safely recycled.

Fact: TBBPA is chemically bound into the plastic matrix of the printed board and therefore is not chemically available (for leaching or offgassing) during use.

Fact: Metals are reclaimed from waste printed boards through incineration. Regulated, controlled incineration of bromine- and chlorine-containing materials does not pose a problem for human health or the environment.

Ranking Criteria: The presence of toxic substances in electronics perpetuates the toxic cycle – during reprocessing of electronic waste and by using contaminated secondary materials to make new products.

Fact: The World Health Organization and the European Commission Scientific Committee on Health and Environmental Risks (SCHER) conducted separate, comprehensive scientific assessments of TBBPA and both found TBBPA to be safe for human health and the environment.

Fact: Current best management of end-of-life circuit boards is energy and metals recovery through controlled incineration. Regulated, controlled incineration of bromine- and chlorine-containing materials does not pose a problem for human health or the environment.

Ranking Criteria: The issue of toxicity is overarching. Until the use of toxic substances is eliminated, it is impossible to secure “safe” recycling.

Fact: Regulated, controlled incineration of bromine- and chlorine-containing materials does not pose a problem for human health or the environment.

IPC (www.IPC.org) is a global trade association based in Bannockburn, Ill., dedicated to the competitive excellence and financial success of its 2,700 member companies which represent all facets of the electronics industry, including design, printed board manufacturing, electronics assembly and test. As a member-driven organization and leading source for industry standards, training, market research and public policy advocacy, IPC supports programs to meet the needs of an estimated $1.7 trillion global electronics industry. IPC maintains additional offices in Taos, N.M.; Arlington, Va.; Garden Grove, Calif.; Stockholm, Sweden; Moscow, Russia; Bangalore, India; and Shanghai, Shenzhen and Beijing, China.

Apr 24, 2018 -

IPC Assembly Quality Benchmark Study Open to Participants, Survey Deadline Extended to April 30

Apr 18, 2018 -

IPC Hand Soldering Competition Winner Crowned at Global Industrie/Midest 2018 in Paris

Apr 12, 2018 -

Don Dupriest Elected to Chair Top IPC Standards Leadership Committee

Apr 03, 2018 -

North American PCB Industry Rebound Continues IPC Releases PCB Industry Results for February 2018

Apr 02, 2018 -

IPC Pulse of the Electronics Industry Survey Shows Strong Business Outlook

Mar 26, 2018 -

IPC Global Assembly Equipment and Solder Statistical Programs Ope

Mar 22, 2018 -

IPC Urges Trump Administration to Take Measured Approach in Levying Higher Tariffs on Electronics from China

Mar 14, 2018 -

IPC Volunteers Honored for their Contributions to the Electronics Industry at IPC APEX EXPO 2018 More than 300 awards presented

Mar 14, 2018 -

IPC Issues Call for Participation for IPC APEX EXPO 2019

Mar 12, 2018 -

Yusaku Kono and Pierre-Emmanuel Goutorbe Receive IPC Rising Star Awards

902 more news from Association Connecting Electronics Industries (IPC) »

Apr 24, 2018 -

Koh Young Technology to Demo New Level of Connectivity at NEPCON China 2018

Apr 24, 2018 -

Al Bickner Joins Intrinsic Quality, LLC.

Apr 24, 2018 -

90 in 90: Koh Young America Delivers Every Day in 1Q

Apr 24, 2018 -

Libra Industries Offers Complete AOI Traceability

Apr 24, 2018 -

IPC Assembly Quality Benchmark Study Open to Participants, Survey Deadline Extended to April 30

Apr 24, 2018 -

Techcon Systems Announces New Territory Sales Manager

Apr 24, 2018 -

Pickering Interfaces Expands Range of 2A PXI Fault Insertion Switching

Apr 24, 2018 -

iNEMI Co-Hosts Automotive Session at SMTA Europe’s Electronics in Harsh Environments Conference

Apr 24, 2018 -

PDR Joins Forces with USM Reps in Mexico

Apr 24, 2018 -

PAC-Global and CEME Now Represent Saki in the Southern US and Mexico

See electronics manufacturing industry news »

IPC Criticizes Bad Science, Methodology In Greenpeace Electronics Guide news release has been viewed 998 times

  • SMTnet
  • »
  • Industry News
  • »
  • IPC Criticizes Bad Science, Methodology In Greenpeace Electronics Guide
Custom Conformal Coating Masks