SMT, PCB Electronics Industry News

IPC and IPCA Comment on India's Proposed E-Waste Rules 2010

Jul 08, 2010

BANNOCKBURN, IL — Working together to address the latest round of proposed substance restrictions, IPC and the Indian Printed Circuits Association (IPCA) have submitted comments in response to the Indian Government’s Ministry of Environment and Forests draft notification of E-waste (Management and Handling) Rules 2010. Specifically, IPC is concerned that the proposed Chapter V, Reduction in the use of hazardous substances (RoHS) in the manufacture of electrical and electronic equipment will have a negative impact on the global and Indian electronics industry and will fail to accomplish the Ministry’s goal of environmentally sound management of electrical and electronic equipment waste.

In its comments, IPC explains that the simultaneous restriction of the 20 substances identified in Chapter V, Schedule III of the proposed draft regulation will not contribute to the environmentally sound disposal of electronic products and proposes that a scientific evaluation of substances be conducted in order to ensure that alternatives provide a benefit to human health and the environment. “IPC urges the Ministry to implement a scientifically-based methodology for restricting substances that includes a full life-cycle assessment of the substances and possible alternatives in order to accomplish the goal of maximum human health and environmental protection,” says Fern Abrams, IPC director of government relations and environmental policy.

Several substances included in Schedule III have been proven to be safe for human health and the environment and should not be restricted under the Ministry’s proposal. For example, Tetrabromobisphenol-A (TBBPA), the most common flame retardant used in more than eighty percent of printed boards, has been safely used for decades. The World Health Organization and the European Commission Scientific Committee on Health and Environmental Risks (SCHER) conducted separate, comprehensive scientific assessments of TBBPA and both found TBBPA to be safe for human health and the environment.

Noting a study of lead-free solder conducted by the U.S. EPA, IPC warns of the environmental trade-offs when restricting substances and blindly substituting one for another. Following the European Union’s restriction of the use of lead in electronics under the RoHS Directive, the EPA study evaluated the environmental impacts of tin-lead solder versus lead-free alternative solders and found that the increased energy use associated with the higher operating temperatures required for manufacturing lead-free soldered electronics would cause greater negative impacts on the environmental than tin-lead soldered electronics. “There should be clear and compelling evidence that potential alternatives are available, are reliable and are preferable from a life cycle perspective,” cautions Abrams. “Until life cycle assessments are conducted proving that the environmental and human health impacts across the alternative’s life cycle are better than the substances being replaced, the Ministry should not restrict any substances.”

IPC also urged the Ministry to consider removing medical devices and monitoring and control instruments, Categories V and VI, respectively, from the list of product categories covered because of their extreme complexity and suggested the institution of a phase-in plan for medical devices and monitoring and control equipment, similar to that proposed for the revision of the European RoHS Directive. Along those lines, IPC asked the Ministry to harmonize the list of substances for restriction with the current RoHS Directives in the European Union and China to help Indian manufacturers compete globally.

To view IPC’s comments, visit http://www.ipc.org/Comments-and-Testimony.

IPC (www.IPC.org) is a global trade association based in Bannockburn, Ill., dedicated to the competitive excellence and financial success of its 2,700 member companies which represent all facets of the electronics industry, including design, printed board manufacturing, electronics assembly and test. As a member-driven organization and leading source for industry standards, training, market research and public policy advocacy, IPC supports programs to meet the needs of an estimated $1.7 trillion global electronics industry. IPC maintains additional offices in Taos, N.M.; Arlington, Va.; Garden Grove, Calif.; Stockholm, Sweden; Moscow, Russia; Bangalore, India; and Shanghai and Shenzhen, China

Feb 22, 2018 -

IPC Issues Position Paper on Priorities for an Ambitious EU Industrial Policy Strategy Supports skills gap closure, R&D incentives and strong IP protection

Feb 19, 2018 -

IPC Releases New IPC/PERM-2901, Pb-free Design and Assembly Implementation Guide IPC-PERM-2901 addresses the impact of Pb-free on reliability and service life for aerospace, defense and high-performa

Feb 14, 2018 -

Show Floor Sells Out for IPC APEX EXPO 2018

Feb 12, 2018 -

IPC Invites Industry Leaders to Submit Poster Abstracts for IPC APEX EXPO 2018 in San Dieg

Feb 08, 2018 -

IPC STEM Outreach Program Introduces Students to the Electronics Industry at IPC APEX EXPO 2018

Feb 05, 2018 -

Industry 4.0 Gets Significant Boost at IPC APEX EXPO 2018 More than 20 companies to participate in IPC CFX Showcase

Jan 31, 2018 -

IPC Welcomes New Senior Director of Education Programs

Jan 28, 2018 -

IPC’s Enterprise Membership Option Simplifies Dues Structure

Jan 22, 2018 -

Salary Budgets are Rising, Says New IPC Salary Study

Jan 11, 2018 -

IPC North American EMS and PCB Statistical Programs Open

882 more news from Association Connecting Electronics Industries (IPC) »

Feb 22, 2018 -

KIC demonstrates smart factory technologies with IPC CFX communication at APEX

Feb 22, 2018 -

MicroCare Offers Higher Performance Critical Cleaning Solutions at IPC APEX Booth #2909

Feb 22, 2018 -

Latest Conference Proceedings Now Available in SMTA Knowledge Base

Feb 22, 2018 -

Scienscope to Exhibit Flexible X-ray Component Reel Counter at productronica China

Feb 22, 2018 -

IPC Issues Position Paper on Priorities for an Ambitious EU Industrial Policy Strategy Supports skills gap closure, R&D incentives and strong IP protection

Feb 22, 2018 -

Data Logging: Intelligently and Efficiently

Feb 22, 2018 -

KDPOF Enables Seamless Optical Networks Integration

Feb 22, 2018 -

XJTAG Announces DFT Assistant for Zuken CR-8000 PCB design suite

Feb 21, 2018 -

Joseph Stockunas, Nordson Corporation Corporate VP, Appointed to SEMI Foundation Board of Trustees

Feb 21, 2018 -

VJ Electronix Hires Industry Expert to Continue Strengthening Global Sales and Services

See electronics manufacturing industry news »

IPC and IPCA Comment on India's Proposed E-Waste Rules 2010 news release has been viewed 940 times

Six Sigma Training

SMT Assembly machines