SMT, PCB Electronics Industry News
  • SMTnet
  • »
  • Industry News
  • »
  • Tulane University Study Finds Dodd-Frank Conflict Minerals Regulations to be One Hundred Times More Costly than SEC Estimate

Tulane University Study Finds Dodd-Frank Conflict Minerals Regulations to be One Hundred Times More Costly than SEC Estimate

Oct 24, 2011

A Tulane University economic analysis, which drew heavily on an IPC survey of the electronics industry, assessed the costs of implementing the Dodd-Frank conflict minerals regulation to be $7.93 billion - more than one hundred times greater than the estimate prepared by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) of $71.2 million. The study, “A Critical Analysis of the SEC and NAM Economic Impact Models and the Proposal of a Third Model in View of the Implementation of Section 1502 of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act,” was prepared at the request of U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, a co-sponsor of the conflict minerals provisions included in the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act.

The Tulane study underscores the need for the SEC to be conscious of the high costs of implementation,” says Tony Hilvers, IPC vice president of industry programs. “The SEC must utilize all reasonable options to lessen the burden of implementation, the most important of which is a phasing-in of the regulations to allow industry the time to work with their complex global supply chains to develop traceability and compliance data.”

The Tulane analysis compared the SEC estimates to the findings of a study by the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM). It also relied on data gathered by the IPC survey of manufacturers in the electronics supply chain. The analysis was conducted by Tulane graduate student Chris Bayer with contributions from Dr. Elke de Buhr of the Payson Center for International Development at Tulane University Law School.

According to Bayer, “Evidence is the best guide, and our economic impact analysis of Dodd-Frank Section 1502 relies on findings from IPC’s 2011 survey. The new law calls for transparency in the mineral sector supply chain and our paper suggests that its implementation will require significant effort on the part of affected companies.”

IPC’s report, “Results of an IPC Survey on the Impact of U.S. Conflict Minerals Reporting Requirements,” was part of a set of extensive comments submitted by IPC for the SEC’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. The survey, which was conducted by IPC’s market research department, collected data from 60 electronics manufacturing services companies, printed circuit board manufacturers, electronics materials suppliers and equipment suppliers.

The Tulane study also supports issues raised by IPC and other industry commenters, including the need to establish, for a transition period, a category for conflict minerals whose origin cannot be determined. The regulations proposed by the SEC require that conflict minerals be identified as either conflict free or as associated with conflict. A legal brief, filed by WilmerHale® on behalf of IPC, outlined the SEC’s authority to adopt a phase-in approach, by both virtue of the statutory text of Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act and the Commission’s general exemptive power under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.

The Tulane University economic analysis may be viewed at http://tinyurl.com/3bl8ntg. For more information about the IPC survey and IPC initiatives in the area of conflict minerals, visit www.ipc.org/minerals.

 


IPC (www.IPC.org) is a global trade association based in Bannockburn, Ill., dedicated to the competitive excellence and financial success of its 3,000 member companies which represent all facets of the electronics industry, including design, printed board manufacturing, electronics assembly and test. As a member-driven organization and leading source for industry standards, training, market research and public policy advocacy, IPC supports programs to meet the needs of an estimated $2.02 trillion global electronics industry. IPC maintains additional offices in Taos, N.M.; Arlington, Va.; Stockholm, Sweden; Moscow, Russia; Bangalore, India; and Shanghai, Shenzhen and Beijing, China.

Oct 17, 2017 -

PCB Prototype Sales Trends Often Diverge from PCB Market Trends According to New IPC Report

Oct 17, 2017 -

IPC APEX EXPO 2018 Educational Programs Highlight Technology’s Accelerating Speed of Change Registration Now Open, Show Floor More than 95% Sold

Oct 11, 2017 -

Nate Carson Joins IPC as New Director of Business Development

Oct 05, 2017 -

IPC Releases 2017 Quality Benchmark Study for Electronics Assembly

Sep 30, 2017 -

North American PCB Order Growth Boosts Book-to-Bill Ratio

Sep 28, 2017 -

IPC Hand Soldering Competition to “Heat Up” productronica 2017

Sep 27, 2017 -

IPC Welcomes Trump Administration’s Framework on U.S. Tax Code

Sep 20, 2017 -

New IPC Studies Show World PCB Market Up in 2016 as North American Market Shrinkage Slows World PCB Production and Annual North American PCB Industry Reports Released

Sep 19, 2017 -

IPC Invites Industry Leaders to Submit Poster Abstracts for IPC APEX EXPO 2018 in San Diego

Sep 18, 2017 -

Excel Electronics, Inc. Earns IPC J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610 Qualified Manufacturers Listing

857 more news from Association Connecting Electronics Industries (IPC) »

Oct 17, 2017 -

ITW EAE to Display Latest Advances in Electronics Assembly Equipment at Productronica Show

Oct 17, 2017 -

KIC and SmartRep introduce real-time dashboard, traceability and data analytics at productronica

Oct 17, 2017 -

Focused IR Rework Technology from PDR to be Displayed in the Tecnolab Booth at productronica – Hall A2, Booth 459

Oct 17, 2017 -

Monitor Your Cleaning Process with ANALYST Data Services – Visit KYZEN in Hall A4, Booth 314 at productronica

Oct 17, 2017 -

CyberOptics Demonstrates New MRS-Enabled AOI, SPI and CMM Solutions at productronica Germany

Oct 17, 2017 -

Scienscope Announces X-ray Lineup for productronica

Oct 17, 2017 -

Nordson Test & Inspection Announces Lineup for productronica

Oct 17, 2017 -

Vi TECHNOLOGY prepares for a busy productronica

Oct 17, 2017 -

Best Rated Cost, Flexibility & Technology – MIRTEC’s MV-6 OMNI 3D AOI System at productronica

Oct 17, 2017 -

Microtronic GmbH to Have a Strong Presence with Its Suppliers at productronica

See electronics manufacturing industry news »

Tulane University Study Finds Dodd-Frank Conflict Minerals Regulations to be One Hundred Times More Costly than SEC Estimate news release has been viewed 885 times

  • SMTnet
  • »
  • Industry News
  • »
  • Tulane University Study Finds Dodd-Frank Conflict Minerals Regulations to be One Hundred Times More Costly than SEC Estimate
SMT Spare Parts and Feeders

HeatShield Gel- thermal PCB shield during reflow