Printed Circuit Board Assembly & PCB Design SMT Electronics Assembly Manufacturing Forum

Printed Circuit Board Assembly & PCB Design Forum

SMT electronics assembly manufacturing forum.


Wave Solder - Small production - Opinion

Views: 3608

#52194

Wave Solder - Small production - Opinion | 25 October, 2007

Hello,
I'm considering to buy my first wave solder machine. We have small production, so we need an small machine, like bechtop wave solder machines.

I have read that small machines as Novastar 8S, 12S, has some problems with complex PCB boards. Our PCB are 4 layers (170 x 290 mm).

I�m thinking in ERSA ETS250. Does anyone know about the quality of ERSA machines?
Any recommendation?

Thanks!

reply »

#52218

Wave Solder - Small production - Opinion | 27 October, 2007

We do very little wave soldering, maybe once a week.
We have been running a Novastar Spartan 8S for years with very good results. I do wish we had the wider 12S for the wider boards, but it has only come up once in 7 years.

I think there is a lot to be said for running a small wave solder machine like this. With less flux and solder you can keep the machine very clean with fresh flux and solder, much easier than a large machine. Heat up time is minimal and with little pot contamination due to the small pot and fresh solder, the solder joints are great.

But to your point on complex boards, we really have not run anything too complex.

These machines are around on the used market as well, often with very little use.

reply »


RDR

#52237

Wave Solder - Small production - Opinion | 31 October, 2007

Small waves are fine, biggest problem is the little to no preheat length. This is reason that complex boards cannot be soldered without defects. They also do not handle thick PCBas very well either because of same issue. Most of these "benchtops" have very short laminar flow wave nozzles as well that can induce bridging when the leads are longer than about .1 or so.

They work good for getting the majority of your solder joints formed but they will never perform at the level of a grown up machine.

ATF in Germany had some decent units that may fit the bill for you. They are basically electroverts that are downsized. Electrovert parts are used in many areas which is a plus in my opinion.

Russ

reply »

Manufacturing Software

 Reflow System